Half of shoppers surveyed have lost money on an international order

Where an online seller is based changes how much U.S. shoppers trust it, and a new EveryMarket survey put numbers on how much. 1,000 U.S. adults rated their comfort buying from unfamiliar sellers in eight countries, and the numbers are in. 83% would be comfortable buying from a seller based in Canada. Just 38% say the same of one based in India, a wider trust deficit than China’s. The shoppers themselves know where the gap comes from. 78% admit they have assumed a product was lower quality or less safe mainly because of the country it came from. Only 22% say they judge the brand and product instead. The findings arrive a year after the rules changed. The de minimis exemption that let packages under $800 enter the country duty free ended for all countries in August 2025, and the behavior it governed is mainstream: 76% of respondents have bought from a seller based outside the U.S., and 27% do it routinely. A year into the new fee regime, this survey suggests the biggest barrier to international shopping predates the fee changes and outruns any one trade dispute. Shoppers carry a ranking in their heads, and they bring it to every listing.

Key findings

  • 83% of U.S. adults surveyed are comfortable buying from an unfamiliar seller in Canada. Only 38% say the same of India, which ranks below China’s 43%.
  • 78% admit they have judged a product’s quality or safety mainly by its country of origin.
  • 50% have lost money on an international order, and 66% admit buying from a seller they didn’t fully trust, domestic or foreign, because the deal was too good.
  • 64% refuse to buy medications from an unknown international seller, more than twice the 30% who refuse electronics.
  • 50% have abandoned an international cart over shipping, customs or surprise fees, yet only 7% name fees as their biggest worry before buying.
  • 37% would pay nothing extra for a Made-in-USA label, and only 7% would pay a premium above 20%.
  • 62% say a U.S.-based marketplace handling payment, returns and refunds would be enough to make them try an unfamiliar international brand.

The trust gap runs country by country, and China isn’t at the bottom

Chart on surveyed U.S. shoppers' comfort with international sellers by country The trade cycle handed shoppers country-specific reasons for caution. Washington ended duty-free treatment for Chinese parcels in May 2025 before extending the suspension worldwide, and Temu and Shein raised U.S. prices ahead of the change. By late August, most Indian goods faced a combined 50% U.S. tariff , a penalty Washington unwound this February after New Delhi agreed to stop buying Russian oil. The survey asked a more basic question: when the seller is unfamiliar, does the country on the listing change how you feel? It does. Every respondent rated all eight countries on the same four-point comfort scale, which makes this a within-person comparison rather than eight separate polls. The ranking:
  • Canada 83%
  • The United Kingdom 77%
  • Japan 70%
  • Germany 69%
  • South Korea 56%
  • Mexico 53%
  • China 43%
  • India 38%
The same shoppers are more than twice as comfortable with a Canadian seller as an Indian one. And the bottom of the list belongs to a country largely absent from trade headlines. India sits below China on net comfort, which points to a confidence gap broader than any one trade fight. The ranking measures what U.S. shoppers believe before they click rather than what sellers in any country actually deliver, and for an unfamiliar seller that belief usually decides the sale.

Most shoppers admit the bias is theirs

Survey chart about country-of-origin assumptions affecting product quality perceptions Survey researchers rarely get respondents to name their own country-of-origin bias on the record. This one did. 78% of respondents say they have assumed a product was lower quality or less safe mainly because of where it came from. 24% say they do it often, 40% sometimes and another 14% say they’ve caught themselves doing it and now try to judge products individually. That last group may be the most telling. One in seven shoppers describes country bias as a habit they are actively working against, which means they consider it a flaw in their own judgment rather than a sound heuristic. This is the mechanism under the country ranking. By the shoppers’ own account, the gap between Canada and India runs on reflex, a habit of judgment they bring to the listing before any product detail loads.

The deal still wins anyway

Survey chart on choosing deals despite doubts about sellers For all that caution, 66% of respondents admit they have bought something from a website or seller they didn’t fully trust, domestic or foreign, because the deal was too good to pass up, and 26% have done it more than once. Only 14% say they walk away from an untrusted seller no matter how cheap it gets. The gamble has a price tag. 50% of respondents have lost money on an international order because the product was fake, never arrived, arrived damaged or couldn’t realistically be returned. 22% lost $50 or more. The youngest shoppers absorb the worst of it and keep going. 64% of Gen Z respondents (18 to 29) have lost money on an international order, against 45% of Gen X (46 to 61), yet Gen Z is also the segment most likely to buy internationally as a routine part of how they shop. Getting burned deters them less than the trust ranking would predict.

The red line is the medicine cabinet

Survey chart comparing caution about international purchases across product categories Counterfeit enforcement coverage concentrates on sneakers, luxury goods and electronics. Consumer anxiety points somewhere else. Asked which categories they would absolutely refuse to buy from an unknown international seller, respondents drew the line at things they swallow:
  • Medications 64%
  • Vitamins and supplements 62%
  •  Baby formula 59%
  • Food and beverages 56%
The categories that dominate seizure headlines barely register by comparison. Only 30% refuse electronics and 31% refuse children’s toys. Medications draw more than twice the refusal rate of electronics. And there’s almost no constituency for risk here: just 10% of respondents say they’d consider buying any of these categories internationally, even from a seller they trusted. Enforcement priorities and consumer fears have drifted apart. Marketplace policing follows brand value. Shopper anxiety follows what goes into their bodies and their children’s bottles.

Fees kill carts that fear never touches

Survey chart on international cart abandonment and unexpected fees Before buying from an overseas seller, respondents worry most about counterfeits (32%) and packages that never arrive (28%). Only 7% name unexpected customs, duties or fees as their top concern. Then they reach the checkout. 50% of respondents have abandoned an international purchase because of shipping charges, customs duties or surprise fees, and 32% have done it more than once. Add those who came close and it reaches 67% of the sample. The fear is about fraud. The abandonment is about the final price. This blind spot has grown more expensive. Since the de minimis exemption ended in August 2025, low-value imports that once cleared customs duty free now carry duties and processing costs. The Baymard Institute’s benchmark research has long identified surprise costs at checkout as the leading fixable cause of cart abandonment across e-commerce. This survey isolates the same pattern for cross-border orders in the first full year of the new rules. The fee problem also carries the widest education divide in the survey. 57% of bachelor’s degree holders say undisclosed customs or duty fees would make them swear off a seller for good, against 27% of respondents with a high school education or less, a roughly 30-point gap. Income tracks the same way: 55% of households earning $100,000 to $249,999 treat undisclosed fees as a permanent dealbreaker, against 32% of households under $25,000. The shoppers with the most financial cushion hold the hardest line on transparency. The ones with the least keep the door open, and stay exposed to the fees.

Patriotism has a price ceiling, and it’s low

Survey chart on the price premium shoppers would pay for Made in USA labeling How much extra is a U.S.-made label actually worth to shoppers? The survey measured it, and the answer is thin. 37% of respondents would pay nothing extra for a U.S.-made product over a similar-quality import. They’d buy whichever gave better value. Among those willing to pay something, most cluster in the single digits: 41% would pay between 1% and 10% more. Only 7% would pay a premium above 20%. Behavior under actual price pressure looks the same. Asked what they’d do if tariffs pushed a product they regularly buy up 20% to 30%, only 12% said they’d simply pay it. The rest would delay, substitute, shop around or quit the product altogether. The Conference Board found something similar in 2025. It reported that the influence of the Made-in-USA label on repurchase decisions fell 18% between 2022 and 2025, based on a survey of 3,000 U.S. adults, with price sensitivity crowding out country-of-origin loyalty. Tariffs and trade tensions have moved this survey’s respondents too. 52% say they’ve become less willing to buy from overseas sellers, but 38% report no change at all, saying price and quality matter more to them than trade policy.

The fix shoppers want is boring

Survey chart on what would make shoppers try an unfamiliar international brand Asked what single thing they would change about international shopping, respondents didn’t reach for inspiration. 35% chose guaranteed fraud protection and refunds when something goes wrong, more than double the next answer, full pricing upfront at 17%. The same procedural instinct shows up in what would unlock a first purchase from an unfamiliar international brand. For skincare and wellness products, 49% point to hundreds of verified reviews from U.S. customers, the top answer by a wide margin. Influencer endorsements finish last at 13%. Reviews beat creators nearly four to one. 62% of respondents say a U.S.-based marketplace handling payment, returns and refunds would be enough to make them try an international brand they’d never heard of, and a money-back guarantee with easy returns ranks second among trust unlocks at 43%. The patience window stays narrow either way: 68% cap acceptable international shipping at three weeks, and 53% need a discount of at least 20% before they’ll pick an unfamiliar international seller over a trusted U.S. one. The wish list amounts to the consumer protections shoppers already expect at home, extended across a border.

Summary

The confidence gap in cross-border shopping turns out to be less about geopolitics than about accountability. Respondents rank the world’s sellers on a steep curve and freely admit the ranking lives in their own heads. Then most of them take the gamble anyway, and half have lost money on an international order along the way. The market looks less closed than underserved. Shoppers keep asking for the same basics: honest pricing at checkout and a refund that actually comes through when something goes wrong. The countries at the top of the trust ranking didn’t get there overnight. The survey suggests any seller, from anywhere, can borrow that trust faster than they can build it, if a system shoppers recognize stands behind the transaction.

Methodology

To understand how U.S. adults approach international online shopping, EveryMarket surveyed 1,000 adults across the country via Pollfish in August 2026. Participants answered 20 questions about their comfort buying from sellers in eight countries, their experiences with international orders, product categories they avoid and what would increase their trust in unfamiliar international sellers. Responses were analyzed by demographic groups to identify trends and disparities. The sample is an unweighted online panel. It skews younger and more female than the U.S. adult population: respondents 62 and older make up 7.0% of the sample, 59.0% of respondents are female and 26.9% report household incomes under $25,000. Findings describe the surveyed population and are not weighted to census benchmarks. Several questions (Q7, Q8, Q9 and Q14) allowed multiple responses, so percentages on those questions total more than 100. All eight countries in the comfort ranking were rated by the same respondents on the same four-point scale, making country comparisons within-respondent rather than between separate samples.

Fair Use Policy

Users are welcome to utilize the insights and findings from this study for noncommercial purposes, such as academic research, educational presentations, and personal reference. When referencing or citing this article, please ensure proper attribution to maintain the integrity of the research. Direct linking to this article is permissible, and access to the original source of information is encouraged.

Comments

Leave a Reply